Why the soulquest *couldn't* have been a ret-con.

[elisi]

Look! A fandom post! I've been meaning to write this down for ages, and suddenly remembered today. And then thought - why not? It is after all why I'm here.

Also, if I remember correctly, I have stormwreath to thank for this flawless proof.


So, let's look at some dates. 'Seeing Red' aired on 7th of May 2002 and tried to make us think Spike blamed the chip for everything:

SPIKE: It's the chip! Steel and wires and silicon. It won't let me be a monster. And I can't be a man. I'm nothing.

'Villains' aired on the 14th of May and it was this episode that more than any other tried to make people believe that Spike wanted the chip out:

SPIKE: Thinks she's better than me. Ever since I got this bleeding chip in my head, things ain't been right. Everything's gone to hell.
DEMON: And you want to return to your former self.
SPIKE: Yeah.

So, did they change the outcome at the last minute? Or is it just that the execution of their mislead was rather clumsy? Well, lets look at the script for 'Grave', dated 27th March 2002 - that is MORE THAN A MONTH before SR aired:

SPIKE (cont'd)
So, give me what I want. Make me
what I was... so Buffy can get what
she deserves.

VOICE
Very well.

A GNARLY DEMON HAND reaches out to Spike's bare chest

VOICE (cont'd)
Your soul is returned to you.

As the hand touches him, Spike throws his head back and SCREAMS in agony...


QED (Unless of course Joss can travel in time...)

Comments

[mikeygs.livejournal.com]

Well, the dates aren't really solid because the scripts are written after the story is broken down by the group.

But yeah, your basic argument is sound. Buffy filmed more than one episode at a time and that part of Grave would have most likely been in the can by the time Seeing Red even aired, much less Villains.

Haters need to let it go 'cause, you know, even it was *was* retcon (which it wasn't), it's still canon.

[elisi]

Buffy filmed more than one episode at a time
My guess would be that they filmed all of Spike's Africa scenes at the same time (since he had to go away for another job). So filming-wise there's probably just days between 'Villains' and 'Grave'.

it's still canon
Exactly. (Unlike, say... S8! Heh.)

[mikeygs.livejournal.com]

My guess would be that they filmed all of Spike's Africa scenes

Yep. That and the entire sequence with the battles and all isn't really *that* long, so to wrap up the set, then come back to it just isn't efficient filmmaking. It's similar with the scenes at Revello (filmed in Torrance), they were usually done in chunks rather dumbly hauling the production back and forth.

S8 and this are apples and oranges. ;) If they were 4 years earlier and we didn't have both Joss and Marti lamenting how exhausted and out of ideas they were, I might include it. Also if they were on TV (I mean they could've recast the characters since apparently having the artwork look like the actors isn't important). :P

[elisi]

That and the entire sequence with the battles and all isn't really *that* long, so to wrap up the set, then come back to it just isn't efficient filmmaking.
Especially since they did it becaue JM was going off to film something else...

If they were 4 years earlier and we didn't have both Joss and Marti lamenting how exhausted and out of ideas they were, I might include it.
It's like you read my mind... (And incidentally this is why I'm much more excited about AtS S6 - they were planning it out and then couldn't do it!

I mean they could've recast the characters since apparently having the artwork look like the actors isn't important
Ouch! But I'm right there with you! (My davice - buy Spike:Asylum. I'll write up a proper review of some sort after issue 4 comes out, since I don't feel like tearing S8 to pieces before I discover to what degree it deserves it.)

Oh and I should be posting schmoopy Spuffy soon (either tomorrow or Monday) which I think you should enjoy! :)

[deborahc.livejournal.com]

Oh and I should be posting schmoopy Spuffy soon (either tomorrow or Monday) which I think you should enjoy! :)

Yay!