I don't actually care who Harry ends up with, but so far all the direct quotes I've seen say nothing about Hermione should have been with Harry, just that ending up with Ron might have been a mistake. It's just the Harry/Hermione shippers making the leap that if she's not with Ron, she MUST end up with Harry, because apparently it's impossible that she meet anyone else, or stay single. :P
It's just the Harry/Hermione shippers making the leap that if she's not with Ron, she MUST end up with Harry, because apparently it's impossible that she meet anyone else, or stay single. :P Well, obviously! *g*
because apparently it's impossible that she meet anyone else, or stay single. :P
Stranger jumping in, sorry—I couldn't see that and not yell approval. In JKR's world, teenage relationships always seem to hold and divorce is unheard of ;)
It's terribly simple. The good guys are always stalwart and true, the bad guys are easily distinguished by their pointy horns or black hats, and we always defeat them and save the day. No one ever dies, and everybody lives happily ever after. (BtVS S2.07 'Lie To Me')
My first reaction was a chortle and a thumbs-up sign, and my second was thinking of A Song of Ice and Fire (my mind makes that connection too often these days) and laughing even harder. XD
Stranger jumping in, sorry—I couldn't see that and not yell approval. In JKR's world, teenage relationships always seem to hold and divorce is unheard of ;) This is actually my main gripe. And not just relationships. All these characters' lives seem to be set by things that happened when they were 17.
Quite right =P Plot-wise, it figures since that's the key moment, but… why that epilogue? It's fond, but I would have preferred an open ending. Oh well ;P
Hahaha, oh god, she's said it! =P That certainly feels a bit odd, lol. I've never believed in that ship much, personally, but if the author herself makes remarks like that…
In the best of all possible worlds Ron/Hermione fans would take it in their stride and think up ways to make the ship work all the same (people grow, so do relationships…), and the unconvinced would nod and move on. In the real world… who said "ship war"? XD
Don't do that to me! I'll stare at the gif for five minutes in a row now! (I kind of hide in the corner with my heap of HP friends sometimes, my mind just goes "Yeah, HP is cool and my OTP of eight years is cool, but just give me all the Who things now." In itself that is no problem, but when people hope to see me produce more HP writing… ahem ;P)
Mine goes back to… age ten at least, but probably a lot earlier than that… I don't even know, either. XD Disney movies. Living with characters in your head is a thing…
Oh, that's actually really interesting. I thought the Hermione/anyone but Ron shippers were already ignoring the Epilogue completely and so this interview shouldn't matter to them... but I'm probably terribly wrong. *is afraid to look at ONTD*
It amuses me that after she spent seven books leading to the Ron/Hermione Harry/Ginny couplings, she now comes out with this. Maybe she's trying to turn attention away from the fact that her adult books aren't that popular? Or are they? I don't know because I have no interest in them.
Time gives us all perspective? And her detective books (written under a pseudonym before she was 'unmasked') are apparently pretty good. So I think it's just nostalgia... Which will lead to vicious fighting! Oh boy.
When I read it earlier I found myself more fascinated by the "for very personal reasons, not for reasons of credibility" bit. I wonder what on earth in her personal life made her feel this would be the perfect ending?
The Draco/Hermione shippers will be so pleased - the couple I read both see that original pairing ending in divorce and, now, that is more or less canon!
When I read it earlier I found myself more fascinated by the "for very personal reasons, not for reasons of credibility" bit. I wonder what on earth in her personal life made her feel this would be the perfect ending? Yes, that's interesting. And I never saw them as a bad match really - it was Harry/Ginny I never really got. Mostly because I didn't think Ginny was ever fleshed out.
The Draco/Hermione shippers will be so pleased - the couple I read both see that original pairing ending in divorce and, now, that is more or less canon! Heh. But whom would Ron end up with?
Same thought about Ginny and Harry/Ginny - and I as I am re-reading HP & HBP at the moment, and I am trying to look at the way the relationships are established with open mind - I see the work that went into Ron/Hermione, but harry/ginny is just there. Luna is really more believable, absolutely.
I see the work that went into Ron/Hermione, but harry/ginny is just there This. I still remember thinking about it after book 6, and all I knew about Ginny was that she liked quidditch.
And I never saw them as a bad match really - it was Harry/Ginny I never really got. Mostly because I didn't think Ginny was ever fleshed out. I was never really against Harry/Ginny. If nothing else it seemed entirely innocuous, if out of left field. But I've had people able to explain it to me in a way that made sense. I would have liked to have seen a little more substance in the books.
It wasn't even that there was not a lot to Harry/Ginny - it's that I never got a grip on Ginny herself. She's Ron's younger sister and she likes quidditch. And that's really it.
I have too many feelings about this for something I don't actually care about.
The predominant one being that, while I don't generally subscribe to the whole 'writer is dead' thing and do think it matters what the writer meant, at the same time YOU FINISHED THE DAMN SERIES ALREADY AND YOU DON'T GET TO TAKE IT BACK.
Secondarily, while our Dynamic Trio were generally the lest interesting thing about the books for me and their teenage romantic foibles even painfully more so, at least I had the consolation that she didn't put Harry together with Hermione. Thank goodness.
The predominant one being that, while I don't generally subscribe to the whole 'writer is dead' thing and do think it matters what the writer meant, at the same time YOU FINISHED THE DAMN SERIES ALREADY AND YOU DON'T GET TO TAKE IT BACK. LOL. And she can't! But like someone says above, what does it say about her own issues? Stephenie Meyer was so very obviously dealing with a ton of stuff in Twilight, but why did Ron & Hermione have to end up together for J.K to be happy?
Secondarily, while our Dynamic Trio were generally the lest interesting thing about the books for me and their teenage romantic foibles even painfully more so, at least I had the consolation that she didn't put Harry together with Hermione. Thank goodness. Heh. I just wish he'd married Luna...
LOL. And she can't! But like someone says above, what does it say about her own issues? Stephenie Meyer was so very obviously dealing with a ton of stuff in Twilight, but why did Ron & Hermione have to end up together for J.K to be happy? See, to me that felt like the more mature and interesting pairing, and Harry/Hermione would have been . . . well, if not wish fulfillment exactly, then entirely too pat. Of course she ends up with him because he's the hero character. I suppose Ron/Hermione has a validation of the everyman element about it. Ron's like a Xander who I don't want to strangle all the time--though, frankly, I think that deserves a bit of validation.
I say this not having actually read this interview or with any intention to . . .
Heh. I just wish he'd married Luna... Oooooo, it's been awhile . . . I think I wanted Luna/Neville. But that may have been a function of my brain pairing up the odd characters that I liked in the hopes that they'd end up with more page-time.
See, to me that felt like the more mature and interesting pairing, and Harry/Hermione would have been . . . well, if not wish fulfillment exactly, then entirely too pat. Of course she ends up with him because he's the hero character. *nods* I never really shipped anyone as such, but Harry/Hermione would have been dull.
I suppose Ron/Hermione has a validation of the everyman element about it. Ron's like a Xander who I don't want to strangle all the time--though, frankly, I think that deserves a bit of validation. Hah. Also it's a far more interesting pairing, because they argue and there are a lot more sparks.
I say this not having actually read this interview or with any intention to . . . Well I only read the tiny bit I linked to, but to be fair JK doesn't say Hermione 'should have ended up with Harry', just that Ron was probably not the best match.
Oooooo, it's been awhile . . . I think I wanted Luna/Neville. But that may have been a function of my brain pairing up the odd characters that I liked in the hopes that they'd end up with more page-time. I hear you.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif){kind=small}
no subject
no subject
Well, obviously! *g*
no subject
Stranger jumping in, sorry—I couldn't see that and not yell approval. In JKR's world, teenage relationships always seem to hold and divorce is unheard of ;)
no subject
(BtVS S2.07 'Lie To Me')
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
This is actually my main gripe. And not just relationships. All these characters' lives seem to be set by things that happened when they were 17.
no subject
no subject
In the best of all possible worlds Ron/Hermione fans would take it in their stride and think up ways to make the ship work all the same (people grow, so do relationships…), and the unconvinced would nod and move on. In the real world… who said "ship war"? XD
no subject
no subject
I'll happily go back to shipping one-sided Bellatrix/Voldemort and Lucius/Narcissa and not care about main characters now ;)
no subject
no subject
no subject
Go on, Harry Potter, Harry Potter, Harry Potter! /Puppet Pals
no subject
*cheers*
no subject
Huh? But that is perfectly normal!
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
*tiptoes to have a look*
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
I'm staying out of this fight...O_o
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
nice one, JKR!
Harry/Luna=4ever!!!!!!
no subject
no subject
The Draco/Hermione shippers will be so pleased - the couple I read both see that original pairing ending in divorce and, now, that is more or less canon!
no subject
Yes, that's interesting. And I never saw them as a bad match really - it was Harry/Ginny I never really got. Mostly because I didn't think Ginny was ever fleshed out.
The Draco/Hermione shippers will be so pleased - the couple I read both see that original pairing ending in divorce and, now, that is more or less canon!
Heh. But whom would Ron end up with?
no subject
no subject
This. I still remember thinking about it after book 6, and all I knew about Ginny was that she liked quidditch.
no subject
I was never really against Harry/Ginny. If nothing else it seemed entirely innocuous, if out of left field. But I've had people able to explain it to me in a way that made sense. I would have liked to have seen a little more substance in the books.
no subject
no subject
I've never read HP, but I am amused by the word 'revealed' as if the author has authority over that.
I take it this is why I've been seeing Joss prefers Spuffy posts the last day or two...
no subject
Ah, but fandom will still be fighting...
I take it this is why I've been seeing Joss prefers Spuffy posts the last day or two...
Oooh, could be. Mind you, I couldn't care less what Joss says.
no subject
no subject
no subject
The predominant one being that, while I don't generally subscribe to the whole 'writer is dead' thing and do think it matters what the writer meant, at the same time YOU FINISHED THE DAMN SERIES ALREADY AND YOU DON'T GET TO TAKE IT BACK.
Secondarily, while our Dynamic Trio were generally the lest interesting thing about the books for me and their teenage romantic foibles even painfully more so, at least I had the consolation that she didn't put Harry together with Hermione. Thank goodness.
no subject
LOL. And she can't! But like someone says above, what does it say about her own issues? Stephenie Meyer was so very obviously dealing with a ton of stuff in Twilight, but why did Ron & Hermione have to end up together for J.K to be happy?
Secondarily, while our Dynamic Trio were generally the lest interesting thing about the books for me and their teenage romantic foibles even painfully more so, at least I had the consolation that she didn't put Harry together with Hermione. Thank goodness.
Heh. I just wish he'd married Luna...
no subject
See, to me that felt like the more mature and interesting pairing, and Harry/Hermione would have been . . . well, if not wish fulfillment exactly, then entirely too pat. Of course she ends up with him because he's the hero character. I suppose Ron/Hermione has a validation of the everyman element about it. Ron's like a Xander who I don't want to strangle all the time--though, frankly, I think that deserves a bit of validation.
I say this not having actually read this interview or with any intention to . . .
Heh. I just wish he'd married Luna...
Oooooo, it's been awhile . . . I think I wanted Luna/Neville. But that may have been a function of my brain pairing up the odd characters that I liked in the hopes that they'd end up with more page-time.
no subject
*nods* I never really shipped anyone as such, but Harry/Hermione would have been dull.
I suppose Ron/Hermione has a validation of the everyman element about it. Ron's like a Xander who I don't want to strangle all the time--though, frankly, I think that deserves a bit of validation.
Hah. Also it's a far more interesting pairing, because they argue and there are a lot more sparks.
I say this not having actually read this interview or with any intention to . . .
Well I only read the tiny bit I linked to, but to be fair JK doesn't say Hermione 'should have ended up with Harry', just that Ron was probably not the best match.
Oooooo, it's been awhile . . . I think I wanted Luna/Neville. But that may have been a function of my brain pairing up the odd characters that I liked in the hopes that they'd end up with more page-time.
I hear you.