elisi: Edwin holding a tiny snowman (Girl with a Sword by sandy_s)
elisi ([personal profile] elisi) wrote2005-06-08 10:28 am

A thought on B/A in S3

For most of us, I think, the B/A relationship in S3 is very frustrating. The two of them seem to go backwards and forwards with no real rhyme or reason until Angel finally leaves at the end of the season.

I watched ‘Lover’s Walk’ last night (happy sigh). This brought on some thoughts and I *think* I might have found a reasonable excuse for the behaviour:

In ‘Lover’s Walk’ of course, Buffy gives Angel that wonderful speech that she seemed to completely forget come season’s end:

Buffy: We're not friends. We never were. And I can fool Giles, and I can fool my friends, but I can't fool myself. (shakes her head) Or Spike, for some reason. What I want from you I can never have. You don't need me to take care of you anymore. So I'm gonna go.

Now of course Spike’s visit and insights helped this along, but something else happens in this episode too: They get their SAT scores. And Buffy’s are very good. It gets mentioned over and over again, although of course Cordelia is the most blunt:

Cordelia: Well, I think this is great! Now you can leave and never come back!

For the first time since she was called, Buffy can actually contemplate a future without Slaying. A future where she might not die young. And all that’s keeping her in Sunnydale really is - Angel. He’s very much part of the Slayer-side of her I think. A Slayer doesn’t think about the future, about children and education. A Slayer can have a boyfriend who doesn’t age, because she probably won’t ever get old. But if she can leave... that changes things. If she can let Faith be Miss Sunnydale in the Slayer Pageant, then where does that leave Angel? If there is the possibility for a normal life, she has to let go of those things that can’t work.

The events of “Amends’ do not help. She’s suddenly desperate not to lose him completely - to be abandoned. So in the next few episodes she appears to have forgotten the lesson she learned in ‘Lover’s Walk’ - she tries to ‘be friends’.

But then of course Faith goes over to the dark side. And I think that with her new shiny future suddenly taken away, Buffy falls back on Angel. She is the Slayer again. She won’t be leaving Sunnydale. The normal life that she might have had has vanished, so why not hook up with him again? Of course it doesn’t work like that...

ETA: Why does Angel stay for so long? I think it's important to remember that he spent the previous 100 years doing nothing much at all - and the last 20 living on the streets. Buffy was his mission, his reason to change his life. Without her what would he do?

[identity profile] lillianmorgan.livejournal.com 2005-06-08 10:29 am (UTC)(link)
If she can let Faith be Miss Sunnydale in the Slayer Pageant, then where does that leave Angel?
Even Joyce mentions that Buffy can let Faith be the Slayer and go on to other things, doesn't she? I forget the episode - was it Lover's Walk? I have to say that the SAT scores were always a bit much for me - it sorta seemed as if it popped out of the air.
It'd be interesting to chart when Buffy's sense of purpose about being the Slayer starts, stops, really kicks in; does she have it in Season 3 like she does in Season 5? Is it always there? In essence, is she a bit of a control freak/in tune with her destiny and wouldn't really have given over the Slayer gig to Faith? Who knows?
That was a long ramble not about Bangel.
but I can't fool myself. (shakes her head) Or Spike, for some reason.
That line always gets me. I'm so glad they brought him back :)
molly_may: (I am braver than you - Jems)

[personal profile] molly_may 2005-06-09 03:30 pm (UTC)(link)
It'd be interesting to chart when Buffy's sense of purpose about being the Slayer starts, stops, really kicks in; does she have it in Season 3 like she does in Season 5?

I think she feels a strong sense of duty throughout the series, but that her real sense of purpose kicked in after the enjoining spell and "Restless". After that she talks a lot less about the idea of having a life without being the Slayer, and she takes her training up to a new level in S5.