![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Entry tags:
DW 4.2
Just very quick thoughts. (meta, as usual)
I have links to longer and more in-depth reviews below. For me *this* stood out:
Doctor: "Don't you think I've done enough? History's back in place and everyone dies."
OUCH OUCH OUCH OUCH OUCH! We really see the consequences of S3 here, and I love it. He lives to save, and yet he can't save those he most wants - couldn't save the Time Lords, couldn't save the Master. And then of course we get Donna, whom I adore so very much, and who I really think needed the cuteness and happy solution of the Adipose, because she - more than any of the other companions so far (bar Jack maybe, but that's different) - gets to see the dark side of the Doctor, and has since the beginning. And she is just so wonderfully human:
Donna: "Not the whole town - just save *someone*."
And I think he does it for her.
Because this *also* ties in with 'Voyage of the Damned':
"But if you could decide, Doctor, who lives and who dies... that would make you a monster." [from memory, sorry if it's inaccurate]
There is a sense of 'damned if he does, and damned if he doesn't'... if he saves someone on a whim, what does that make him? I think this is why he needs a Companion - someone to be his moral center, because he is totally messed up, and he knows it. He knows what he has to do, but when it comes to what he *can* do, it gets complicated.
This of course again ties in with the Master storyline in S3, and what happens when a Time Lord decides to play god for real. Yes, the Master was evil and insane, but what he did the Doctor *could* do. (Of course I dealt with this at great length in this essay, so won't do so here.) Where to draw the line is the problem - he has so much power, but using it without becoming a monster (and oh, we saw him cross that line in 'Family of Blood') is the balancing act he keeps trying to get right.
Finally, I LOVE the waterpistol - can't you just see little kids running around playing Doctor Who all summer? "I bloody love you!" indeed! :)
Obligatory pimp:
Review by![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
neadods.
Review byselenak.
Both really excellent, go check them out!
wendymr has been converted to Donna here. :)
I have links to longer and more in-depth reviews below. For me *this* stood out:
Doctor: "Don't you think I've done enough? History's back in place and everyone dies."
OUCH OUCH OUCH OUCH OUCH! We really see the consequences of S3 here, and I love it. He lives to save, and yet he can't save those he most wants - couldn't save the Time Lords, couldn't save the Master. And then of course we get Donna, whom I adore so very much, and who I really think needed the cuteness and happy solution of the Adipose, because she - more than any of the other companions so far (bar Jack maybe, but that's different) - gets to see the dark side of the Doctor, and has since the beginning. And she is just so wonderfully human:
Donna: "Not the whole town - just save *someone*."
And I think he does it for her.
Because this *also* ties in with 'Voyage of the Damned':
"But if you could decide, Doctor, who lives and who dies... that would make you a monster." [from memory, sorry if it's inaccurate]
There is a sense of 'damned if he does, and damned if he doesn't'... if he saves someone on a whim, what does that make him? I think this is why he needs a Companion - someone to be his moral center, because he is totally messed up, and he knows it. He knows what he has to do, but when it comes to what he *can* do, it gets complicated.
This of course again ties in with the Master storyline in S3, and what happens when a Time Lord decides to play god for real. Yes, the Master was evil and insane, but what he did the Doctor *could* do. (Of course I dealt with this at great length in this essay, so won't do so here.) Where to draw the line is the problem - he has so much power, but using it without becoming a monster (and oh, we saw him cross that line in 'Family of Blood') is the balancing act he keeps trying to get right.
Finally, I LOVE the waterpistol - can't you just see little kids running around playing Doctor Who all summer? "I bloody love you!" indeed! :)
Obligatory pimp:
Review by
neadods.Review by
selenak.Both really excellent, go check them out!
wendymr has been converted to Donna here. :)
no subject
Asterix humour indeed! :)
it did deal with some serious issues. When the Doctor realized that it was him who ultimately killed all those people my heart just broke for him. How much do I love Donna putting her hands over the doctor's on that lever?
Same here! I ::heart:: Donna SO much!
I love Rose and Martha, but I'm really digging Donna. I think she's old enough to be secure in herself and stand up to the Doctor when he needs it. It's a much more equal relationship than with either of the main companions in the new series so far.
I keep seeing the word 'sibling-vibe' and I think that works well.
OH, and I loved the squirtgun. Loved it. Figured out how to make screencaps to capture the magic; I'll have to post them after church!
Looking forward to it!
no subject
no subject