elisi: (Girl Doctor)
[personal profile] elisi
Thoughts on the Doctor in S11, a few minor spoilers for the season so far.

N.B. This is not the meta café - this is just a custard cream to go with your tea. :)

The Doctor in S11 is quite different to what we are used to. There are no big victories, no speeches, no trading on her fame or inherent power, no using her name as a weapon.

Some people laud this, some people dislike it. This Tumblr post lays out some interesting points - please go read it, then come back to me:

What do Ryan, Yaz, and Graham actually know about the Doctor?

Now, from a Doylist perspective, maybe Chibnall just wants to return to a more Classic Who mould, maybe he dislikes the Doctor as the all-powerful Lonely God and just wants her to be a renegade traveller like she was in the beginning.

The Watsonian take is far more interesting though.

I have written extensively about how Moffat put the show and the Doctor back together, and we can follow the development quite clearly, right from the first real, serious check on what he had become:

DOCTOR: You think I wanted this? I didn't do this. This, this wasn't me!
RIVER: This was exactly you. All this. All of it. You make them so afraid. When you began, all those years ago, sailing off to see the universe, did you ever think you'd become this? The man who can turn an army around at the mention of his name. Doctor. The word for healer and wise man throughout the universe. We get that word from you, you know. But if you carry on the way you are, what might that word come to mean? To the people of the Gamma Forests, the word Doctor means mighty warrior. How far you've come.

A Good Man Goes To War

And then onto Twelve who turned that problem inwards (‘Am I a good man?’) until he found the answer:

DOCTOR: I really didn't know. I wasn't sure. You lose sight sometimes. Thank you! I am not a good man! I am not a bad man. I am not a hero. And I'm definitely not a president. And no, I'm not an officer. Do you know what I am? I am an idiot, with a box and a screwdriver. Just passing through, helping out, learning.
Death in Heaven

Now, having this epiphany this didn’t automatically make things easier, but it certainly highlighted the way forward, even as Twelve clearly decided that he was at the end of his life anyway. But then came Twice Upon a Time, and this moment:

GLASS WOMAN: The Doctor has walked in blood through all of time and space. The Doctor has many names.
DAVROS [OC]: The Destroyer of Worlds.
GLASS WOMAN: The Imp of the Pandorica. The Shadow of the Valeyard. The Beast of Trenzalore. The Butcher of Skull Moon. The Last Tree of Garsennon. The Destroyer of Skaro. He is the Doctor of War.
(The images disappear.)
DOCTOR 1: What, what was that?

Twice Upon A Time

I see this moment as the one driving the very last step, the Doctor seeing himself through his past self's eyes. Much like Kazran did not change his ways until he was faced with his child-self, so the Doctor's final change is quite possibly due to this encounter - River asks him what his younger self would think of him, but an idea is never as impactful as a personal experience: to see the First Doctor recoil, bewildered and appalled at what he will become. Is it any wonder that Thirteen strives to be someone her first incarnation would understand and approve of? Trying her best to find her way back to what her intentions were back when she first set off to see the universe.

And then of course there is One’s later comment, just before they go their separate ways:

DOCTOR 1: You've saved him.
DOCTOR: Both of them. Never hurts, a couple fewer dead people on the battlefield.
DOCTOR 1: So that's what it means to be a doctor of war.

Twice Upon A Time

The Doctor has been 'The Doctor of War' (or 'the War Doctor') ever since Eight made the fateful decision to drink of the Sisterhood's potion. A potion that was more symbolic than anything else - it was about deliberately calling forth all his darker traits and leaving 'the Doctor' behind. And regenerating into Nine did not magically change anything back; The Day of the Doctor follows the Doctor down the years, through Ten and Eleven, four hundred years of having committed genocide hanging over him. Is it any wonder Twelve delves into himself to puzzle out what kind of man he really is? And despite everything, he still dies on a battlefield, war trailing in his wake.

And don't forget: Twelve wanted to die. He was old and tired and exhausted. He eventually capitulated, agreeing to regenerate, but it's no wonder that going forwards the Doctor wants to simply 'save a few people on the battlefield', rather than fight the war. To see the 'little people', rather than trying to topple the ones at the top.

So I think that the Doctor – once he’d decided to regenerate after all – made a conscious decision to step back, to use a new regeneration to get ‘back to basics’; to no longer trade in on her fame and reputation but just solve problems on a day to day basis, rather than play judge, jury & executioner - or god, handing out life and death. And in her first episode she lays out her agenda very clearly:

DOCTOR: And if there is one thing I'm certain of, when people need help, I never refuse.
DOCTOR: We're all capable of the most incredible change. We can evolve while still staying true to who we are. We can honour who we've been and choose who we want to be next. […] I'm the Doctor. Sorting out fair play throughout the universe.
YASMIN: Is this normal for you?
DOCTOR: I'm just a traveller. Sometimes I see things need fixing, I do what I can.

The Woman Who Fell To Earth

So, the Doctor is starting anew. She wants to fix things, to 'sort out fair play', to be a referee - and these are all roles away from the spot-light. Where the Doctor would usually step in and take charge, Thirteen does her best to listen to others and find out what actually needs doing (or not) rather than impose her will.

She has of course tried to let go of her past before:

ROSE: Where are you from?
DOCTOR: What does it matter?
ROSE: Tell me who you are!
DOCTOR: This is who I am, right here, right now, all right? All that counts is here and now, and this is me.

The End of the World

Except Thirteen is not a damaged shell of a man who has spent untold years fighting in the worst war in the universe. She has done the work, faced and fought her demons and chosen what kind of person she wants to be, going forward. There is no defensiveness in her replies to her companions' questions, just simple, honest answers - something which may very well be as much for her own benefit as for theirs, re-enforcing to herself what her new path is.

So, the new companions have no reason to believe that she is anything more than what they have seen – an alien time traveller who is incredibly smart and good at technology. However, I think there is a definite sense that she tries to keep her new friends in the dark as to who she really is and what her history has been, what she is capable of. Mostly by omission, but in this scene she actively tries to shut down a conversation that could raise unwelcome questions:

CICERO: Wait. I've heard that name. Aren't you in the Book of Celebrants? Isn't there a whole chapter about you?
DOCTOR: Me? No. Very common name. Anyway, lovely chatting. Must be off. Hope you all get better soon. (She bundles her companions out the door, before sticking her head back around the corner.) I'd say it was more of a volume than a chapter. Just so you know.

The Tsuranga Conundrum

The big question is – will we get a big moment? Will the Doctor be able to live her life the way she wants, or will she be pushed to use/trade on her power/history? To properly use it?

DOCTOR: Don't play games with me. You just killed someone I liked. That is not a safe place to stand. I'm the Doctor, and you're in the biggest library in the universe. Look me up.
(There is a pause, then the shadows withdraw.)
VASHDA NERADA: You have one day.

Forest of the Dead

DOCTOR: Okay. One more. Just one. Is this world protected? Because you're not the first lot to come here. Oh, there have been so many.
(The projection shows the Daleks et al.)
DOCTOR: And what you've got to ask is, what happened to them?
(A run through of all the previous Doctors, then this Doctor steps through the projection with a jacket and bow tie.)
DOCTOR: Hello. I'm the Doctor. Basically, run.

The Eleventh Hour

DOCTOR: Do me a favour. The Fatality Index. Look up The Doctor.
RAFANDO: You have an entry, just like any other sentient being.
DOCTOR: Under Cause Of Death.
(Rafando works his wrist computer. It ticks rapidly as it runs through all matching entries.)
RAFANDO: You do seem to have an impressive record of fatalities credited to you.
(The ticking keeps going, and speeds up.)
RAFANDO: A truly remarkable record.
(The guards retreat.)
RAFANDO: Where are you going? He's unarmed! You are unarmed?
DOCTOR: Always.
(The wrist computer still hasn't stopped scrolling through.)
RAFANDO: You stand alone?
DOCTOR: Often.
RAFANDO: You're the one who should be afraid.
DOCTOR: Never.
RAFANDO: Have a nice day, then.


And what will her companions say then?

DOCTOR: That thing killed hundreds of people.
ROSE: It's not the one pointing the gun at me.
DOCTOR: I've got to do this. I've got to end it. The Daleks destroyed my home, my people. I've got nothing left.
ROSE: Look at it.
DOCTOR: What's it doing?
ROSE: It's the sunlight, that's all it wants.
DOCTOR: But it can't
ROSE: It couldn't kill Van Statten, it couldn't kill me. It's changing. What about you, Doctor? What the hell are you changing into?


DOCTOR: But you've seen it out there. It's beautiful.
DONNA: And it's terrible. That place was flooding and burning and they were dying, and you were stood there like, I don't know, a stranger. And then you made it snow. I mean, you scare me to death.

The Runaway Bride

CLARA: I think I'm more scared of you right now than anything else on that TARDIS.
Journey to the Centre of the Tardis

Because the thing is – making armies turn and run at the mention of her name is nothing more than a normal Tuesday to the Doctor. But 'just passing through, helping out, learning' – that’s a whole different thing. And I can’t find it in me to begrudge her this shot at something new, something simpler. Remember, this is where she stood, not long ago:

DOCTOR: You're not even really here. You're just memories held in glass. Do you know how many of you I could fill? I would shatter you. My testimony would shatter all of you. A life this long, do you understand what it is? It's a battlefield, like this one, and it's empty. Because everyone else has fallen.
Twice Upon A Time

And so she took her own advice:

DOCTOR: You wait a moment, Doctor. Let's get it right. I've got a few things to say to you. Basic stuff first. Never be cruel, never be cowardly, and never, ever eat pears! Remember, hate is always foolish, and love is always wise. Always try to be nice, but never fail to be kind. Oh, and you mustn't tell anyone your name. No one would understand it, anyway. Except – Except children. Children can hear it sometimes. If their hearts are in the right place, and the stars are too, children can hear your name. But nobody else. Nobody else, ever. Laugh hard, run fast, be kind.

And so far - she is keeping to it, despite the pain.


But how long can she carry on?

(no subject)

Date: 15 November 2018 02:08 pm (UTC)
watervole: (Default)
From: [personal profile] watervole
I'm very much liking the 'small story' scenarios.

partly because history is better told through the lives of the people affected by it, and partly because I'm fed up of story-lines where the entire universe is in danger (again).

(no subject)

Date: 16 November 2018 10:47 am (UTC)
watervole: (Default)
From: [personal profile] watervole
Very good point. Little people, like the Hindu husband, can die - and do - and we can mourn them more than we mourn an army because we have come to know him as a person.

The universe only raises a question of how it will be saved, rather than having the same tension.

(no subject)

Date: 15 November 2018 03:51 pm (UTC)
beccaelizabeth: my Watcher tattoo in blue, plus Be in red Buffy style font (Default)
From: [personal profile] beccaelizabeth
good thoughts

(no subject)

Date: 15 November 2018 09:39 pm (UTC)
rahirah: (Default)
From: [personal profile] rahirah
I have loved this season so far because its focused upon stories about people rather than grand cosmic tapestries that eventually fall apart under the weight of their own plot twists.

(no subject)

Date: 16 November 2018 04:07 am (UTC)
jerusha: (tv buff)
From: [personal profile] jerusha
I've really been enjoying this season.

(no subject)

Date: 17 November 2018 01:13 pm (UTC)
purplefringe: Amelie (Default)
From: [personal profile] purplefringe
Going to check back in later when I'm not going out (I feel like I'm always saying this!) but just FYI I *LOVED* this piece of mini-meta, I think it's perfect and insightful and draws a beautiful thread through everything that's happened so far. Also - how do you always find such perfect quotes from the show?? Do you have them all in your head??

(no subject)

Date: 18 November 2018 06:29 pm (UTC)
purplefringe: Amelie (Default)
From: [personal profile] purplefringe
I see this moment as the one driving the very last step, the Doctor seeing himself through his past self's eyes. Much like Kazran did not change his ways until he was faced with his child-self, so the Doctor's final change is quite possibly due to this encounter[...]Is it any wonder that Thirteen strives to be someone her first incarnation would understand and approve of?

This is SUCH a good point and analogy <3 I really like this, as the final step.

Is it any wonder Twelve delves into himself to puzzle out what kind of man he really is? And despite everything, he still dies on a battlefield, war trailing in his wake [...] it's no wonder that going forwards the Doctor wants to simply 'save a few people on the battlefield', rather than fight the war. To see the 'little people', rather than trying to topple the ones at the top.

Again, this is such a perfect, crystal clear summary of everything that's jumbled in my head - thank you for spelling it out! (and OH GOD Twelve still dies on a battlefield - and regenerates on another - argh /o\)

She has of course tried to let go of her past before

I rewatched this ep recently, and I still didn't think to put that together! Wonderful comparison - it really highlights how far the Doctor has come. (EVERY TIME I think about that episode, I just think about how Nine took Rose to see the death of her own planet on her first trip, and just facepalm at how much therapy he needed :P It makes me wonder where Thirteen would have taken her crew first, if she'd had a choice over the matter. Also how she would have reacted to that sort of pushiness, that Nine gets from Rose. Yas and co are much more chill.)

Finally, those quotes about companions fearing the Doctor - beautifully chosen. They ARE speaking to each other, across writers and eras! I love Chakoteya, but it's a proper skill to remember even roughly what you're looking for :)

Ok - Who Time!

(no subject)

Date: 18 November 2018 07:31 pm (UTC)
purplefringe: Amelie (Default)
From: [personal profile] purplefringe


I loved that ep :D The noise I made at the fez scene (which I had avoided watching on CiN) was possibly inhuman. Also the Agatha Christie mention. Also the 'was that too bombastic?' moment (THE META IN THAT) also THIRTEEN'S FACE at the end when Yas asked to see Dan's daughter aaaaah

(no subject)

Date: 19 November 2018 11:03 am (UTC)
purplefringe: Amelie (Default)
From: [personal profile] purplefringe
I look forward to whatever yo do with it in vid form once the season is over.

I have no particular vid ideas yet, so if anything occurs, hit me up :)

But look at Ten & Martha

Ooooh, another v good point. Am going to think about this some more.

(no subject)

Date: 17 November 2018 11:07 pm (UTC)
maia: (Maia)
From: [personal profile] maia
♥ ♥


elisi: van Gogh almond flowers (Default)elisi
April 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 2019