DW 9.11 Heaven Sent

[elisi]

This episode was exquisite. And as a consequence this post is almost more poetry than meta.



The First Second of Eternity





~~~





~~~




It took me two days to make this connection… But oh, isn't it perfect?

Why the two ways? Because either way they’ve got him. They want his knowledge. They leave the wall out of the time loop, as they want him to know that death is not an option:
Either he confesses – or he can punch his way through a wall 400 times stronger than diamond. If he’s stubborn enough to go for the wall (and they know he might be), then he’ll end up on Gallifrey where they can deal with him personally. For them, it’s a win-win scenario.

Although another reason the wall was left out of the time loop was in order to induce despair. And without Clara he would probably have given up...

But there she was - an idea, in his head, refusing to budge.


~~~






The wall was, in many ways, atonement, the price he had to pay to rescue/find/retrieve those he had murdered. Does punching a wall/being in hell for 2 billion years adequately pay his dues? Well, it’s not unreasonable. Certainly he’s earned the right to have his people back, and meet them without that overwhelming guilt he has been carrying.

But, you say, he didn’t kill them! Wasn’t that the whole point of Day of the Doctor? Well now. Let’s talk about Abraham and Isaac and heavenly justice...
The Doctor spent 400 years thinking that he had killed his own kind. And he would have done, if Clara hadn't been there, forcing him to think of a way out. It's like Abraham being willing to sacrifice Isaac - that Isaac ultimately survives is beside the point, it's Abraham's devotion/willingness to kill him that matters. Besides, he's very far from innocent, as his speech to Bonnie above demonstrates.

Gallifrey was Schrodinger's planet? He both killed them & didn't kill them. From Rose and until Day of the Doctor he did press that button. Besides, emotions aren't logical. He's spent centuries steeped in grief and regret and guilt - and probably a lot of anger too.

Which he will be a lot more comfortable showing now...

Plus, as this Tumblr post said:

'I love how some things never change. The Time Lords haven’t even been officially shown yet, and they’re already back to being assholes.'

Which is of course the flipside: The Time Lords, basically, are jerks, and this has now been very demonstrably shown.


~~~




Miniscopes were sideshow attractions which displayed the lives of intelligent and non-intelligent creatures for entertainment. The creatures on display were actually miniaturised and kept in secure micro-environments within the device itself. The specimens were reduced in size by a factor of about 72 and kept this way by a compression field generated by the miniscope. They generally lived through a specific set of events over and over again. Specimens extracted from the field resumed their original size.

Before leaving Gallifrey, the First Doctor knew of the miniscopes (they were not a Gallifreyan invention) and was outraged by their cruelty to the specimens. He campaigned to have them banned. Despite the non-interference policy of the Time Lords, he was successful.
(x)


~~~





~~~


And finally...

I kept these parts of Jesus to a Child in reserve, as I thought I might need them this week:

Comments

[juniperphoenix]

Truth or Consequences

...I'll just be over here slapping myself on the head. Brilliant catch.

[a-phoenixdragon.livejournal.com]

THIS.

Yet another cruelty, methinks.

One of those 'Daddy's watching!!' only Daddy has a razor blade if you are what he deems as 'naughty'. UGH.

[elisi]

I was SO PLEASED! :D

[a-phoenixdragon.livejournal.com]

THIS POST...

OMG...

The miniscopes...I did not know about that. The cruel irony of being trapped in the very thing he protested. And it echoes back to the punishments those who defied Rassilon's cruelty endured.

His non-memory was merciful in a way...but it only fueled his drive. And his anger when he realized he had been trapped. The Time Lords, the High Council, the Gray Council and the Celestial Intervention Agency always did know how to pull his strings and make him dance. I do believe in trying to demonstrated their power and anger (though he did spare them from their own foul stupidity. They would have died if he had left it all behind. And so would the rest of the universe. If they'd've pulled their heads out of their asses, they'd've realized he had a heavy choice - extinction to save the rest of the universe or removal to do the same - but like Daleks, they can't see beyond their own selfish, self-righteousness); they have made the gravest of mistakes. The manipulated him, Clara, Mayor Me (though she was easy...foolish, hot-headed, righteous, bored and quite stupid at times...common sense doesn't last through the ages it seems) and used a prison he had objected to (because Echoes of the Dark Times) to inflict a punishment that (if they stopped to think on it), he really hadn't earned. He saved them. It was unfortunate that the only way he could save them did exactly what the miniscopes did. But that was THEIR fault. Their technology after all...and very fitting, as I'm sure he was punished for deviating from standard Time Lord behavior. But like all dictators, they see their crimes being rendered unto them as special persecution and never equate it to their own wrongs.

I said much the same thing to someone else in their review: too bad they had all these years to reflect, to grow and change. And they didn't take that opportunity. How much you wanna bet they are worse than before. Not fit for the mercy he tried to give them. They were hardly in mind of mercy for anyone else. Foolish asshats. The fact they woke the King of Assholes should have clued the poor Doctor in. I wish they learned. Instead, they just grew stupid.

A small, rather cruel part of ME doesn't feel sorry for them one bit. I'm half afraid the Doctor will break his promise. I know he likely won't. But I wouldn't blame him for 'not being there' if someone choses to do it for him. Meh.

*HUGS*


Pssst...was I the only one thinking Gallifrey from the moment he 'arrived'? The chamber he arrived in, then the room, his mention of the veiled lady, the circular rooms (that could spell his name if moved correctly) - it all reminded me of Gallifrey. So I was not surprised at the reveal. It all made sense, really.

[elisi]

THIS POST... OMG...
♥ ♥ ♥

The miniscopes...I did not know about that. The cruel irony of being trapped in the very thing he protested. And it echoes back to the punishments those who defied Rassilon's cruelty endured.
See, this is why I included that! The second we saw what it was, it was my first thought. Whether all Confession dials work like that, or if they just adapted that one, I don't know. But it makes perfect sense. Simple, effective, easily understood, and - for those who know - an added tie-back to the Classic show. (Miniscopes feature in various episodes, I forget which ones.)

And his anger when he realized he had been trapped. The Time Lords, the High Council, the Gray Council and the Celestial Intervention Agency always did know how to pull his strings and make him dance.
This. They've always used him when they needed him, manipulating him for their own ends...

Their technology after all...and very fitting, as I'm sure he was punished for deviating from standard Time Lord behavior. But like all dictators, they see their crimes being rendered unto them as special persecution and never equate it to their own wrongs.
*nods a lot*

I said much the same thing to someone else in their review: too bad they had all these years to reflect, to grow and change. And they didn't take that opportunity. How much you wanna bet they are worse than before. Not fit for the mercy he tried to give them. They were hardly in mind of mercy for anyone else. Foolish asshats. The fact they woke the King of Assholes should have clued the poor Doctor in. I wish they learned. Instead, they just grew stupid.
Well, we don't know how much time passed for them. But yeah - The Sixth Doctor said it best:

The Doctor: "In all my travelling throughout the universe, I have battled against evil, against power-mad conspirators. I should have stayed here. The oldest civilisation: decadent, degenerate, and rotten to the core. Power-mad conspirators, Daleks, Sontarans, Cybermen - they're still in the nursery compared to us. Ten million years of absolute power. That's what it takes to be really corrupt."

A small, rather cruel part of ME doesn't feel sorry for them one bit. I'm half afraid the Doctor will break his promise. I know he likely won't. But I wouldn't blame him for 'not being there' if someone choses to do it for him. Meh.
I just wonder where they can go from here... Will they bring them back? How would that work in a wider context? They can't go back to being lost...

Pssst...was I the only one thinking Gallifrey from the moment he 'arrived'? The chamber he arrived in, then the room, his mention of the veiled lady, the circular rooms (that could spell his name if moved correctly) - it all reminded me of Gallifrey. So I was not surprised at the reveal. It all made sense, really.
I think everyone was thinking Gallifrey, from last week onwards. And the episode most certainly laid the hints on heavily.

[enevarim]

SIX: The oldest civilisation: decadent, degenerate, and rotten to the core. Power-mad conspirators, Daleks, Sontarans, Cybermen - they're still in the nursery compared to us. Ten million years of absolute power. That's what it takes to be really corrupt.

or Eight and Cass:

CASS: Don't touch me!
DOCTOR: I'm not part of the war. I swear to you, I never was.
CASS: You're a Time Lord.
DOCTOR: Yes, I'm a Time Lord, but I'm one of the nice ones.
CASS: Get away from me!
DOCTOR: Well, look on the bright side. I'm not a Dalek.
CASS: Who can tell the difference any more?

So not only does the Church’s Interdict in Time of the Doctor exactly mirror the Pandorica gambit at the end of series 5, but maybe they had a point and they were right to try to keep the Time Lords from getting back into the universe? The mind boggles...

[a-phoenixdragon.livejournal.com]

The concept 'pinged' dimly, but I couldn't recall it. I haven't seen most of Classic since I was small. Some things stuck with me. For some reason, the mini-scopes didn't. Though the '3-D' paintings also pinged for me. If you think on it, the tech, the idea and function is exactly the same. A painting is a snapshot, though - the mini-scopes are a full-capture.

I'm doing a rewatch (albeit slowly and on halt for a while), but I haven't hit anywhere near mini-scope territory yet, lol!

*HUGS*

[enevarim]

It is a terrible thing that it is so easy to imagine the Time Lords saying “He froze us in a pocket universe, so let’s do the same to him and see how he likes it.”

Never mind that he did it to them to save them all from being burned alive, and they seem mostly to be doing it out of spite and fear. As you say, “I wish they learned. Instead, they just grew stupid.”

(I still think – though I understand it would have made for a less dramatic story – that sensible Time Lords would just have stolen the information from the Doctor’s brain patterns while the copy of his brain was in the teleporter. But your comment clears up why that didn’t happen. It isn’t “sensible” Time Lords we’re dealing with here...)

[a-phoenixdragon.livejournal.com]

Well, if you think about it, they never were sensible. S'why he never had any patience with them in the first place.

And to make it worse, they added another 2 billion years to their own clock. Maybe they were even aiming for an eternity - just to make their point - as I'm sure they were convinced (forgetting how the tech actually works) that he would eventually give up. Or worse never even try. After all, they would eventually give up. (Which is hilarious when you think on it, because if they gave up their sense of vengeance, the Doctor never would have been in that mini-scope in the first place).

Most of the creatures were likely unaware of what was happening to them (which makes it worse). The Doctor only had so much time before he became aware (which was engineered in, I'm sure). The whole thing registers as a poorly thought out temper tantrum. But once again, they show that they know just enough of him to put him through his paces.

They were always spiteful. And arrogant. And narcisstic. And power-mad, power-hungry and corrupt. They LIKE it that way. They will never see that he was trying to save them. They will see that he was trying to punish them for all the slights they visited upon them. They had no patience with waiting for him to find them. After all, if it was THEM, they would have left him to rot.

He doesn't work that way. Think that way. Something they never 'got' but always relied upon.

Every time I write about Gallifrey, I incorporate this type of thinking and behavior for his race. I hate to admi I find it fascinating, if repulsive. I also find it (sadly) echoes some of our worst human qualities.

And WOW, I ramble too much...

[promethia_tenk]

His non-memory was merciful in a way...but it only fueled his drive. And his anger when he realized he had been trapped. The Time Lords, the High Council, the Gray Council and the Celestial Intervention Agency always did know how to pull his strings and make him dance. I do believe in trying to demonstrated their power and anger . . . they have made the gravest of mistakes.

'Oh, big, big mistake, really huge. Didn't anyone ever tell you there's one thing you never put in a trap, if you're smart, if you value your continued existence, if you have any plans about seeing tomorrow, there's one thing you never, ever put in a trap . . . me.'

This week should be interesting . . .

[unfeathered]

Beautiful. Love the Truth or Consequences realisation - I so didn't get that, and it's such lovely echoing/foreshadowing! And the miniscope, which I also didn't get despite having watched Carnival of Monsters when the Horror Channel showed it a few weeks ago! My mind this time instinctively went to virtual reality, because that's so common these days, but I love the idea that he actually was a tiny, tiny Doctor for two billion years. Three would have boggled!

I am going to have to watch this ep again (of course I am - there's so much to see) because I'd always assumed the confession dial must be something the Doctor came up with himself, because it's *his* confession dial, and also because in the light of this ep punishing himself for two billion years really seems like something he would inflict on himself, albeit it would have to be a scenario drawn from his subconscious or something because obviously he didn't know what was going on right from the start. However, your point (and others') about it being a creation of the Time Lords all along makes much more sense; I just need to get my head round it. It would certainly shed an interesting light on the fact that when a Time Lord thinks they're dying they send it to their best friend - to stop the Time Lords getting hold of it, because what it actually is is a way of getting a dying Time Lord's most secret secrets out of him so they can use them for their own ends!

Or perhaps this is not what a confession dial is supposed to be; the Time Lords just hijacked the Doctor's one for their own ends? Lots to think about!

[elisi]

Beautiful. Love the Truth or Consequences realisation - I so didn't get that, and it's such lovely echoing/foreshadowing!
IKR? Something went click in my head, and ohhh.

And the miniscope, which I also didn't get despite having watched Carnival of Monsters when the Horror Channel showed it a few weeks ago! My mind this time instinctively went to virtual reality, because that's so common these days, but I love the idea that he actually was a tiny, tiny Doctor for two billion years. Three would have boggled!
LOL, yes. And I think that is if looks like a miniscope, then it probably is one. Esp as the Doctor would be able to spot virtual reality in a second. (See 'Amy's Choice' and 'The God Complex'.)

I am going to have to watch this ep again (of course I am - there's so much to see)
I've only watched it twice, but want to rewatch it so much more, because it's just so gorgeous.

However, your point (and others') about it being a creation of the Time Lords all along makes much more sense; I just need to get my head round it.
I think it's a combination... It's a perfectly constructed nightmare, where they've used his fears in order to create a place where they'll be able to gather his confessions.

It would certainly shed an interesting light on the fact that when a Time Lord thinks they're dying they send it to their best friend - to stop the Time Lords getting hold of it, because what it actually is is a way of getting a dying Time Lord's most secret secrets out of him so they can use them for their own ends!
Well... I can see it as making sense, generally? Dead Time Lords would be uploaded to the Matrix - it's only sensible to make sure that they don't harbour any deadly secrets before adding them - plus, as you say, useful!

Or perhaps this is not what a confession dial is supposed to be; the Time Lords just hijacked the Doctor's one for their own ends? Lots to think about!
WHO KNOWS! Although as you say, it's certainly interesting.

[promethia_tenk]

I'd always assumed the confession dial must be something the Doctor came up with himself, because it's *his* confession dial, and also because in the light of this ep punishing himself for two billion years really seems like something he would inflict on himself, albeit it would have to be a scenario drawn from his subconscious or something because obviously he didn't know what was going on right from the start.
Nah, I'm with you. I loved this episode from 'go' because . . . well, obviously it is amazing. But I loved it even more once I realized that, as this is the Doctor's confession dial (and because it is a confession dial), then he can be seen at least partially as the architect of his own suffering and thus the whole thing works as a metaphor for guilt.

[thisbluespirit]

Truth or consequences! *slaps forehead*

Lovely meta - or poetry!! ;-)

[elisi]

Thank you! I wish I had more time... Although I'm sure that tonight will bring us plenty more.

[sea_thoughts]

Ah, Eliot.

Who then devised the torment? Love.
Love is the unfamiliar Name
Behind the hands that wove
The intolerable shirt of flame
Which human power cannot remove.
We only live, only suspire
Consumed by either fire or fire.

and

We die with the dying:
See, they depart, and we go with them.
We are born with the dead:
See, they return, and bring us with them.

and finally

With the drawing of this Love and the voice of this Calling

We shall not cease from exploration
And the end of all our exploring
Will be to arrive where we started
And know the place for the first time.

I didn't know about the miniscopes but it makes sense given the Time Lord attitude to other forms of life... they are really awful.

Those two verses of Jesus to a Child remind me of Last Christmas because Danny came back to Clara on a cold night and told her that it would be okay but she couldn't give up and had to keep fighting. It seems only fitting that Clara would do the same for the Doctor.

[elisi]

Ah, Eliot.
YAY! Someone pulled out the Eliot part. ♥

(I wish I had more time for poetry...)

I didn't know about the miniscopes but it makes sense given the Time Lord attitude to other forms of life... they are really awful.
Not sure how clear my cut & pasted information was - they didn't invent them, or use them, or anything. But the Doctor got them to use their power to have them banned in the universe generally... *goes to edit post* (This is why I shouldn't post at 12.30am!)

Mind you, it makes perfect sense for them to use something like that.

Those two verses of Jesus to a Child remind me of Last Christmas because Danny came back to Clara on a cold night and told her that it would be okay but she couldn't give up and had to keep fighting. It seems only fitting that Clara would do the same for the Doctor.
Ohhhh. Oh now I want a Clara/Danny vid to that song. (Although it'd be unbearably sad, of course.)

[ragnarok-08.livejournal.com]

Yes I enjoyed the episode as well, and this post really cemented why I loved it so much.

[elisi]

::is very pleased::

[purplefringe.livejournal.com]

Aaaaaaaah god there was SO MUCH IN HERE OMG. (lol, as you could probably tell from my ramblings on my blog earlier in the week, my brain is overwhelmed by it all) This is fabulous - miniscopes! Of course! I would never have realised that, but you're absolutely right. And they got a shout out in Robot of Sherwood just last season, so Moffat has clearly been thinking of them.

The Truth or Consequences thing was wonderful. And that's not the only recurring theme - the whole idea of repeating a scenario over and over again to completion, then forgetting about it was in the Zygon Inversion too. And kind of in Ashildr/Me's storyline - you get the impression that she could have the exact same conversation with the Doctor over and over again, hundreds of years apart, and not remember. And the idea of constant surveillance, as by all the TV monitors in Heaven Sent, and all the cameras in Sleep No More, and all the times the Doctor and Clara have communicated over video phone conversations this season. Gallifrey's been watching this whole time...

On a random tiny note - I really liked how the Doctor meeting that little boy alone in the Gallifreyan desert mirrored his meeting with young Davros at the start of this season.

AAAAAAAAAH I AM SO EXCITED ABOUT TONIGHT /o\

[elisi]

Aaaaaaaah god there was SO MUCH IN HERE OMG.
I KNOW!!!

lol, as you could probably tell from my ramblings on my blog earlier in the week, my brain is overwhelmed by it all
Yet to read that... BUSY week. Hence only posting this so very late.

This is fabulous - miniscopes! Of course! I would never have realised that, but you're absolutely right. And they got a shout out in Robot of Sherwood just last season, so Moffat has clearly been thinking of them.
It made me very happy. And I've not really seen anyone else draw that conclusion.

The Truth or Consequences thing was wonderful.
:)

nd that's not the only recurring theme - the whole idea of repeating a scenario over and over again to completion, then forgetting about it was in the Zygon Inversion too. And kind of in Ashildr/Me's storyline - you get the impression that she could have the exact same conversation with the Doctor over and over again, hundreds of years apart, and not remember.
Oh, VERY NICE. Also, for anyone who thinks the Doctor is a jerk for messing with other people's memories... He sure gets a dose of his won medicine. *pets him*

And the idea of constant surveillance, as by all the TV monitors in Heaven Sent, and all the cameras in Sleep No More
YOU FOUND A POSITIVE THING IN Sleep No More! Woo!

and all the times the Doctor and Clara have communicated over video phone conversations this season. Gallifrey's been watching this whole time...
They do that... (I did wonder what they were doing. They found the right universe in Time of the Doctor, yet they've not been coming back, banners blazing.)

On a random tiny note - I really liked how the Doctor meeting that little boy alone in the Gallifreyan desert mirrored his meeting with young Davros at the start of this season.
I think I was going to mention that and forgot COMPLETELY.

Thanks for reminding me.

AAAAAAAAAH I AM SO EXCITED ABOUT TONIGHT /o\
FIFTY MINUTES!!!

[ever-neutral.livejournal.com]

It took me two days to make this connection… But oh, isn't it perfect?

!!!!!!!!!! A;KSJ;DJSKJDS;JDS OH. MY. DOG. (This is why you are the superior Who stan.)

It's like Abraham being willing to sacrifice Isaac - that Isaac ultimately survives is beside the point, it's Abraham's devotion/willingness to kill him that matters.

This. Hence why the naysayers' virulent objections to Day of the Doctor on the grounds that it "whitewashed" the Doctor / made him "less heroic" (take your pick) are so baffling to me. The decision was real for him. He can't run from who he knows he is.

'I love how some things never change. The Time Lords haven’t even been officially shown yet, and they’re already back to being assholes.'

Uh huh.

I can't even speak words about the Clara-nes of it all. I am not a person.

Off now to watch the finale. Pray for me.

[elisi]

V. Quickly - enjoy!!!!!!

[cynthia2015.livejournal.com]

The fact that the Time Lords forced the Second Doctor to regenerate was enough for me to know that they were a nasty bunch. They are so pompous.

[elisi]

Yeah, all-round jerks.

The regular people are OK, but the top brass... nope.